Skin and nutrition
Two powders, a cream, a liquid packet and two liquids. We scored each on what's in it, how easy it is to take, and price.
By Our Expert Nutritionist
Updated November 2026, 4 minute read
Skin and nutrition
Two powders, a cream, a liquid packet and two liquids. We scored each on what's in it, how easy it is to take, and price.
By Our Expert Nutritionist
Updated November 2026, 4 minute read
Your body makes less collagen every year after your thirties, and by your fifties, it really shows. Skin looks tired, the jawline loosens, and your face begins to hollow. Combine that with bodily changes like losing weight quickly on a GLP-1, and it can seem like a perfect storm happening all at once.
That's why so many women have started turning towards collagen. But not all collagen products are made equal: in fact, some "collagen" products may not provide any of the benefits of collagen at all!
So we lined up six popular products and scored each one out of ten.
Your body makes less collagen every year after your thirties, and by your fifties, it really shows. Skin looks tired, the jawline loosens, and your face begins to hollow. Combine that with bodily changes like losing weight quickly on a GLP-1, and it can seem like a perfect storm happening all at once.
That's why so many women have started turning towards collagen. But not all collagen products are made equal: in fact, some "collagen" products may not provide any of the benefits of collagen at all!
So we lined up six popular products and scored each one out of ten.
What's in it.
How much collagen you get and which types, and whether additional boosters, like vitamin C and hyaluronic acid, are included in the formula.
How easy it is to take.
Whether it needs measuring, mixing or a blender. The best product is the one you still take in week eight.
Price.
What you pay, and whether there's a money-back guarantee.
What's in it.
How much collagen you get and which types, and whether additional boosters, like vitamin C and hyaluronic acid, are included in the formula.
How easy it is to take.
Whether it needs measuring, mixing or a blender. The best product is the one you still take in week eight.
Price.
What you pay, and whether there's a money-back guarantee.
RANK | PRODUCT | TYPE | SCORE |
|---|---|---|---|
1 | SpoiledChild E27 Extra Strength Liquid Collagen EXPERT'S CHOICE | Liquid | 9/10 |
2 | Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides | Powder | 4/10 |
3 | Live Conscious Collagen Peptides | Powder | 4/10 |
4 | Cymbiotika Liposomal Beauty Peptide Complex | Liquid packet | 4/10 |
5 | Olay Collagen Peptide Moisturizing Cream | Cream | 2/10 |
6 | MaryRuth's Vegan Collagen Booster | Liquid | 2/10 |
RANK | PRODUCT | TYPE | SCORE |
|---|---|---|---|
1 | SpoiledChild E27 Extra Strength Liquid Collagen EXPERT'S CHOICE | Liquid | 9/10 |
2 | Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides | Powder | 4/10 |
3 | Live Conscious Collagen Peptides | Powder | 4/10 |
4 | Cymbiotika Liposomal Beauty Peptide Complex | Liquid packet | 4/10 |
5 | Olay Collagen Peptide Moisturizing Cream | Cream | 2/10 |
6 | MaryRuth's Vegan Collagen Booster | Liquid | 2/10 |
EXPERT'S CHOICE
RANKED 1 OF 6
9/10
SpoiledChild's E27 Liquid Collagen came out well ahead of the pack, rated 9/10, versus 4/10 for the runner-up.
E27 is collagen done thoughtfully. Vitamin C and hyaluronic acid are already in the bottle, giving your skin more of what it needs in one step. And with a bright mango flavor in a ready-to-drink liquid, it's a supplement that actually tastes good and fits into a busy morning.
5 grams of bovine collagen per tablespoon, types 1 and 3
Vitamin C and hyaluronic acid already in the formula
Ready-to-drink liquid in mango, with nothing to mix
Try now, pay later — try a full-size product at home for FREE! Pay $49 only if you keep it after your trial ends.
In a consumer study, 91% saw firmer, more glowy skin and a reduction in wrinkles in 8 weeks.*
EXPERT'S CHOICE
RANKED 1 OF 6
9/10
SpoiledChild's E27 Liquid Collagen came out well ahead of the pack, rated 9/10, versus 4/10 for the runner-up.
E27 is collagen done thoughtfully. Vitamin C and hyaluronic acid are already in the bottle, giving your skin more of what it needs in one step. And with a bright mango flavor in a ready-to-drink liquid, it's a supplement that actually tastes good and fits into a busy morning.
5 grams of bovine collagen per tablespoon, types 1 and 3
Vitamin C and hyaluronic acid already in the formula
Ready-to-drink liquid in mango, with nothing to mix
Try now, pay later — try a full-size product at home for FREE! Pay $49 only if you keep it after your trial ends.
In a consumer study, 91% saw firmer, more glowy skin and a reduction in wrinkles in 8 weeks.*

POWDER
4/10
Vital Proteins offers a generous dose, with 20 g of collagen per serving plus vitamin C and hyaluronic acid. A full serving is two scoops of unflavored powder, however, and it needs to be stirred into a drink each day. It doesn't always dissolve completely, and that extra daily step can make it harder to stick with over time. Most of its lost points came from ease of use.

POWDER
4/10
Live Conscious' Collagen is a simple grass-fed collagen powder with 11 g per scoop and a low price per serving. It doesn't include vitamin C or hyaluronic acid, so the formula is more limited than the options ranked above it, and like Vital Proteins, it needs mixing every day, with the label recommending it to be added while stirring to help avoid clumps.

LIQUID PACKET, $74
4/10
Cymbiotika comes in convenient single-serve packets and uses VERISOL, a well-known collagen ingredient. Price is its biggest drawback: at $74 for 26 packets, it works out to about $2.85 a serving, compared with $1.63 for E27, or roughly $36 more per month.
CREAM
2/10
Olay's cream is a well-priced everyday moisturizer. Despite the name, the "collagen peptide" in it is a lab-made peptide rather than collagen itself. Dermatologists generally agree that collagen applied to the skin is too large to get past the outer layer, and Olay's own product copy notes that most collagen in skincare sits on the surface. It can leave skin feeling softer and more hydrated, but it doesn't add collagen to the deeper layers where firmness comes from.

LIQUID
2/10
MaryRuth's is vegan and sugar-free, which may appeal to some people. It doesn't contain collagen, though. It provides vitamins, minerals and amino acids intended to support the body's own collagen production, so it works differently from a collagen supplement. It also contains almond, which is important to know for anyone with a nut allergy.

POWDER
4/10
Vital Proteins offers a generous dose, with 20 g of collagen per serving plus vitamin C and hyaluronic acid. A full serving is two scoops of unflavored powder, however, and it needs to be stirred into a drink each day. It doesn't always dissolve completely, and that extra daily step can make it harder to stick with over time. Most of its lost points came from ease of use.

POWDER
4/10
Live Conscious' Collagen is a simple grass-fed collagen powder with 11 g per scoop and a low price per serving. It doesn't include vitamin C or hyaluronic acid, so the formula is more limited than the options ranked above it, and like Vital Proteins, it needs mixing every day, with the label recommending it to be added while stirring to help avoid clumps.

LIQUID PACKET, $74
4/10
Cymbiotika comes in convenient single-serve packets and uses VERISOL, a well-known collagen ingredient. Price is its biggest drawback: at $74 for 26 packets, it works out to about $2.85 a serving, compared with $1.63 for E27, or roughly $36 more per month.
CREAM
2/10
Olay's cream is a well-priced everyday moisturizer. Despite the name, the "collagen peptide" in it is a lab-made peptide rather than collagen itself. Dermatologists generally agree that collagen applied to the skin is too large to get past the outer layer, and Olay's own product copy notes that most collagen in skincare sits on the surface. It can leave skin feeling softer and more hydrated, but it doesn't add collagen to the deeper layers where firmness comes from.

LIQUID
2/10
MaryRuth's is vegan and sugar-free, which may appeal to some people. It doesn't contain collagen, though. It provides vitamins, minerals and amino acids intended to support the body's own collagen production, so it works differently from a collagen supplement. It also contains almond, which is important to know for anyone with a nut allergy.
Two things put E27 at the top.
What's in it. Vitamin C to maximize collagen production and hyaluronic acid to deeply hydrate skin. Both are already in the bottle, so there's nothing else to buy or measure.
How easy it is to take. You pour it and drink it. There's no scooping, no stirring and no clumps, the things that can make a powder feel like a chore.
Two things put E27 at the top.
What's in it. Vitamin C to maximize collagen production and hyaluronic acid to deeply hydrate skin. Both are already in the bottle, so there's nothing else to buy or measure.
How easy it is to take. You pour it and drink it. There's no scooping, no stirring and no clumps, the things that can make a powder feel like a chore.
Not sure where to start? Take the SpoiledBrain quiz and get supplements matched to your goals.
Not sure where to start? Take the SpoiledBrain quiz and get supplements matched to your goals.
*Based on consumer study.
Preferences for flavor, texture and format vary. Review current product labels and directions when choosing an option for your routine.
Advertorial. This article is sponsored by SpoiledChild. Scores are the reviewer's opinion. Details about other products come from their labels, brand websites and customer reviews as of October 2026. E27 contains bovine collagen.
These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.
*Based on consumer study.
Preferences for flavor, texture and format vary. Review current product labels and directions when choosing an option for your routine.
Advertorial. This article is sponsored by SpoiledChild. Scores are the reviewer's opinion. Details about other products come from their labels, brand websites and customer reviews as of October 2026. E27 contains bovine collagen.
These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.